Homeowners insurance comparison

Compare homeowners insurance by coverage, not just by price

Two quotes that look $300 apart can protect very different things. Learn what to line up side by side, what policies leave out, and when it is worth switching.

  • Compare dwelling limits, deductibles and exclusions on equal terms
  • Run illustrative premium, deductible and quote calculators
  • Understand claims, renewals and nonrenewal before you need them

Start hereHomeowners Premium Range Estimator

Homeowners insurance comparison

Explore by topic

All guides →

Tools

Homeowners Policy Forms and Related Coverage Compared

Coverage typeHow it worksGood forWatch out for
HO-3 (special form)Dwelling and other structures covered for all risks except those listed as excluded; belongings usually covered for named perils.Most owner-occupied single-family homes in average condition.Belongings are typically named-perils only unless upgraded; flood and earthquake excluded.
HO-5 (comprehensive form)Dwelling and belongings both covered on an open-perils basis, often with richer settlement terms.Newer or higher-value homes and owners with many belongings.Costs more, and not every carrier offers it in every state.
HO-2 (broad form)Covers a named list of perils for dwelling and belongings.Older or lower-value homes where an HO-3 is hard to get.Anything not named is not covered, which can surprise buyers.
HO-8 (modified coverage)Older homes insured for repair or actual cash value instead of full rebuild to modern standards.Historic or unusual homes whose rebuild cost exceeds market value.Often will not pay to restore original materials; read the settlement terms.

Comparison →

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare homeowners insurance quotes fairly?

Ask every carrier for the same dwelling limit, liability limit, deductible and endorsements, then compare premiums. Also check how roofs and belongings are settled (replacement cost or actual cash value). The quote checklist lists what to match.

Is homeowners insurance required by law?

No state requires it, but nearly every mortgage lender does, and the lender can buy expensive coverage for you if yours lapses. Owners without a mortgage should still insure against a total loss and liability claims.

Does homeowners insurance cover floods and earthquakes?

Standard policies exclude both. Flood is covered by a separate National Flood Insurance Program or private policy, and earthquake by a separate policy or endorsement where available. Both can have waiting periods and large deductibles.

Why did my premium go up when I made no claims?

Rates reflect rebuild costs, weather losses and reinsurance costs across a whole region, not only your history. Rising replacement costs also push your dwelling limit and premium up. Shop at renewal and ask about discounts and a higher deductible.

What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?

Replacement cost pays to repair or replace with new materials, while actual cash value subtracts depreciation for age and wear. The difference can be thousands of dollars on a roof or on furniture.

How much dwelling coverage do I need?

Insure the cost to rebuild the home, not what it would sell for or what you paid. Rebuild cost depends on size, finishes and local labor. Your insurer can provide an estimate, and you can compare it with a contractor's view.

Can an insurer refuse to renew my policy?

Yes, in most states for permitted reasons, with advance written notice whose length varies by state. If it happens, shop the standard market and consider your state's FAIR Plan or insurer of last resort as a backstop.

Will filing a claim raise my rates?

Often it can, and claims show up on CLUE reports that other insurers see. Small claims near your deductible are sometimes not worth filing. Ask your agent for a hypothetical discussion without naming your policy, then decide.

How this site is made

Keystone Cover is an independent information project. Guides are drafted with the help of AI writing tools and checked against official and primary sources before publication; see our Editorial Policy. We are not affiliated with any provider mentioned on the site and do not sell products or services.